If you thought Mariah Carey’s rendition of ‘Hero’ at Sporting Monte-Carlo in Monaco was great then you haven’t seen anything yet! Indeed, the legendary singer, who was once accused of losing her vocal gifts, showcased the the full power of her voice at the intimate event by belting her hits ‘We Belong Together’, ‘My All’ and more.
Carey floated across the Monaco stage as she scaled through her range and wowed the crowd with her incredible voice. Yet, the best part of the show was the fact that she didn’t lip-sync a single note! Watch the footage below to see what I mean:
‘We Belong Together’
‘Can’t Take That Away From Me’
‘My All’
‘Love Hangover’/'Heartbreaker’
‘I’ll Be There (with Trey Lorenz)’
If the anticipation for Carey’s new album wasn’t already high then it just hit the roof! Her voice sounded spectacular here and she took us back to 1999 with the clarity of her voice! There really isn’t anything negative to say about this show so just let the tears of joy flow.
Subscribe to these comments by RSS
You can change your comment avatar at Gravatar.com.
Using this site means you agree and will adhere to all rules, terms, and policies.
That’s why I love her
THE VOICE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! BEST SING ALIVE TBH
I am so excited for her and Xtina to come back and maybe even duet!!
Whoa I thought Trent was stanning but then I watched the clips and I was really blown away. I didn’t think Mariah still had it like that. I’m on board for her new album if she keeps this up
If Ya’ll truely think Mariah wasn’t lippin it at the end of we belong together you as foolish as trent is stupid!!! Pre recorded folks!!! Trent stop trying to fool people with this insanity!! Ughhh!!!
Baffled!!! Cant take that away from me… She nearly died! My All sounds cute in the beginning But then by the end it’s back to straining and wishing she anywhere but on a stage live!!! Bol
She sounds a+++++mazing! Love her forever
@nasjei aasanti
The end of WBT sounds like NONE of her previous performances and it does NOT sound like the track. Are you saying she did a live track for this and a different one for Morocco? You are SO PRESSED. You say the same hateful shit in EVERY post. I’m surprised you didn’t bring up Whitney this time.
LEAVE. Whitney would be ASHAMED of you.
0______________________________0 she sounded really good………I didn’t think she could sing like this anymore. Can’t Take That Away really impressed me.
*screams* MARIAH!!!!!!
Girl I don’t know what you’re doing to your voice but keep it up because it’s working!!! She killed it!!!! <3
@nasjei aasanti: If you really feel that way about Trent, please explain to me why you’re still browsing his website. And it’s OK if you don’t like Mariah, just don’t click on the topic just to troll the ones who do. Go out. Get a hobby. Get a life.
YES!! LET THEM KNOW Ms.Carey!!! Eat them all!! Please!!
She gave me Donna Summers with Love Hanger and she sounded amazing!!!!
Show the world them again vocals Ms.Carey!! I loved this concert, her tone sounds great, her flexibility is back in place, her dynamics are getting back to true form and she seems so much more fluid on stage! Forget your nerves Carey and just slay, slay, slay! I love her vocals so much!
Trent, you’re being biased. This wasn’t that great. She’s still pitchy, inconsistent and cracking. Somehow, Mariah has done irreparable damage to her voice and it’s very obvious. We’re applauding her “legendary” status as opposed to solid vocals. If Beyonce sounded like that or Kelly Rowland, Jennifer Hudson and the rest you’d have every gif and adjective to describe their poor showing.
What I can’t understand is how Mariah’s normal voice is so inconsistent. She can’t sing the verses which are the easiest parts of the songs? Her belts are good, but I think she should just take a long time off, raise “dem babies” and return once every so often. 2 albums a decade is enough considering she’s done SO MUCH music, She can’t really reclaim that 1990-97 reign. She’s had her time, given us her best, she should let music be secondary, tertiary even.
Sing Mariah!!!! Sing!!!!!!!
Mathew & the other hater nobody is here for y’all weak azz comments. She did her damn thing. Her vocals were amazing. F*ck off somewhere. Keep celebrating y’all. GREAT JOB MARIAH !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
“My all” was MY ALL!!!!! The voice is back. She learned the Morocco lesson, she rested her voice and she understood live is best in “Can’t take that away”. She did a great job. She needs to trust herself like this. She’s gonna slay in 2012!
She sounds great! If she keeps doing whatever it is that she is doing, she’ll keep sounding great.
Never been much of a fan but she sounded FANTASTIC
Matthew Charlery-Smith: “She can’t really reclaim that 1990-97 reign. She’s had her time, given us her best, she should let music be secondary, tertiary even.”
That’s insulting to say about someone’s art and talent that they greatly treasure and have been doing their whole life. Music is everything to Mariah. It’s not some thing to do on the side. She does’t need to be putting out albums every other year (and she really hasn’t been) but she can definitely still give us great music. People need to stop trying to count her out. She doesn’t deserve that. And who said she is trying to regain the ’90-’97 reign? She is at a different point in her career now. She doesn’t need to do that.
We know that Mariah’s voice has changed and that she doesn’t sound like the early-mid 90s but that certainly doesn’t mean that she is not amazing and one of the best female vocalists out there.
i give props where props are due and that was the best she has sounded in 10 years
^^^^^^^ Still a hater however………….
Queen Mariah is doing her thing!
Thank God for this musical being we like to call Mariah. She has touched so many lives with her music and she is forever entertaining.
But one good performance out of the last 10? I wouldn’t say her voice is back, this just may be a good night
Go MC! Make your haters your motivators! U better werk!!
LOFL this was sooo pathetic, if you fools honestly think that screetching and trying sounds good, your stupid and bias, go watch my booboo bee’s show, see what a real voice can do, with real power and octives
@Theman4u she’s had many great performances. Shut your mouth & stay out of her post if all u do is complain. You’re a hater as it was stated. @Beyfan you’re a complete utter joke. Everyone has heard Beyonce’s singing and it’s nothing special… Period…………………
THEN WHY MA QUEEN GOT 16 GRAMMIES AND YO TIRED BITCH ONLY HAVE LIKE 5, I mean damn, she’s just a voice, and the voice is tired and horse and sounds shitty. I mean real talk she dont even sound as good as Rihanna, and I hate that retard, but she sound better than Mariah, fo damn sho, want me to send you some of the queens music so you can know what a voice is supposed to sound like?
Every time Mariah gets on stage these days, she improves…this is the best she’s sounded in a very long time.
She also performed Honey at this concert: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XT0E40ESBOs
OMGGG!!!! MARIAH SOUNDS INCREDIBLE IN MONACO! GIRRRL YOU’RE MY LEADER,ALWAYS AND FOREVER!VOCALS WERE ON POINT!!!!!!!
@Beyfan you are a loose cannon. Save the music for yourself. Her music is regular, nothing special. Stop trying so hard. Beyonce is a basic artist, nothing more. Half those grammy’s Beyonce has are gimme awards. Mariah has sold over 200 million records & has eighteen number ones. Thats way more success than Beyonce could ever dream of. She’s also a real songwriter and great artist. She’s not a fraud like others…….
Wow!!!!!!! What voice! Mariah is amazing, her vocals where very impressive. She really is back and in a BIG way!
Mariah really does hold her own I don’t think their is anyone in her league! She is phenominal!
@Beyfan Please bitch, I saw Beyonce on the Ladies First tour….and A. Alicia Keys ate her up! B. I walked out before she even finished the last song “Dangerously In love” because she was trying soooooo hard with her vocal runs that she sounded like a complete mess! She is nothing special…just another artist making it big emulating other artists before them. Funny how she even tried to make her “Star Spangled Banner” sound like Whitney’s. What a joke. And she can’t even write a decent song to save her life…she has to sit around and wait for someone to give her a hit and then claim she wrote it. Anyways, next!
Are we watching the same videos, because these performances was so dull and boring. I would never pay to go to a Mariah concert. Her stage presence is so falt.
Her voice sounds very winy and her notes are flat. She sounds like an amateur up there, and not like a woman who has been in in the business for 20+ years
She was a little pitchy on “Can’t Take That Away From Me,” but at least she sang it live. She sounded really good on “We Belong Together” (I loved how she sang the word “believe” because that alone gave me chills). “My All” was my favorite performance of them all because she sounded really good belting out those notes!
Overall, She did very well and she seemed really happy to be back on stage.
Dear Hater(s) (insert name here),
The crowd was cheering and clapping, so they must have enjoyed the performances and that is all that matters.
I see my queen got bitches preessed and hurt, and I cant blame them if my fave was as lame and boring and stupid and drunk as Mooriah, I’d be pissed too, like feel real low about myself. Wheres I feel faboulous cause I bow down to ma queen, and she makes better music than Mariah, and always had a better voice than the cow too, my girl got them high notes and low notes, HA, eat that, AND ma bitch can dance, Mariah cant do nothin, she need to just go to the old folks home and get her shitty diper changed, and just leave the singin up to a real singer like ma Bey, and to the pressed man, too bad you walked out on my girl slaying Floplicia down.
That crowd looked bored to death. I don’t see anywhere where they’d looked excited. Delusional fans are really reaching
Delusional hater, find a hobby. @Beyfan Loooooooooool, pressed over a fraud??? Are you serious. You are as crazy as she is……. Beyonce makes mediocre music….. Nothing great…….. Beyonce high notes???? You mean forced notes…… Low notes…. ????? Forced as well………….. Beyonce her look, music & persona need to hit the refresh button. She’s been stale for a great while. Mariah is awesome and thats that………….
If Mariah was “Awsome” her ass would be knowin how to dance after like 20 years in this industry, and you just jealous that ma girl got a real voice, that yo chick could never have, you probably jealous cause ma girl is pretteyer than the Moo Cow too. If yo tired bitch is so good, whycome all her albums except like 2 in the last 10 years FLOP harder than anything, wheres ma bitch aint been a flop a day in her life, she makes masterpieces and you will BOW to them
lol @ beyfan, these are the typical delusional bey stans who thinks their Queen would condone their crap. Beyonce started singing because she heard Vision of Love by Mariah and that is how your idol was born. And then she went on steal song credits and blue ivy and everything, thats just her business. but remember its Mariah who invented Beyonce just so you know. And Mariah is a classy diva who doesn’t need to dance or steal to sell records. BYE!
lol beyfan is so pressed!! lololol why dont you spend more time at your Blue Ivy alter or something, you psychopath. LMAO
“THEN WHY MA QUEEN GOT 16 GRAMMIES AND YO TIRED BITCH ONLY HAVE LIKE 5″ Why? You sure you dont know why? Lol, because Mr Knowles bought them sis. You know you know the truth. Gosh you tried it sis, retire now!
This is proof that Mariah’s voice is recovering from pregnancy and whatever from 2008. This is REAL pregnancy, not someone who just gave birth and looked the same as before. But still, I’m just glad that Mariah sung these songs(which she wrote by the way, they werent stolen(;) and i’m just hoping she would do I Still Believe or Side Effects, somewhat lesser known songs from her 13 albums, which has 6 #1 albums, 18 #1 hits, over 200 records sold worldwide.
Mariah’sLamb is just mad as hell My queen is taking her spot, and you lyin as hell, my girl started singin when she was 4, she was 9 when Vision of Love came out, so get yo fackts straight booboo, makin up shit aint cute. And obviously yo girl cant sell records by just singin CAUSE SHE GOT SO MANY FLOPS IF SANGIN WAS ALL IT TAKES FOR HER, SHE’D HAVE NOTHIN BUT GOLD, OUCH DID THAT HURT YOU, I BET IT DID, I BET YOU FEEL REAL CRUNCHY BOWT YO LIFE NOW DONT YOU? Go sit down somewhere, leave that Mariah shit alone, and come stan for a real entertainer, someone who wouldnt degrade her stans by callin us “lambs” I aint no animal so I’d hate that shit, thats fucked up, Im a mutha fuckin person, who bows down to ma queen, I aint no stupid farm animal that needs to be led to a slawterhouse neither, like lambs do.
I betchu I scared them lambs away, shit dont nobody care about her flat ass, look at her audience they hate her, nobody doin nothin, she sucks and the lambs know it!
@Beyfan is clearly an idiot. Your grammar is horrendous. Animal names lol… But you’re fine with being called the Beyhive. Mariah created all of these fan names remember??? You are pointless….
@Theman clearly you just jealous, and I’d rather be a Bee than a fuckin lamb that gets slawtered like yall. STUPID, and maybe you should just go into a closset and sit for a minite because you lookin real stupid fo real, and you know it too, and you know my bitch is the best bitch to do it and you hate her for it too dont you.
Technically the best voice there has ever been in commercial music. Haters will always hate
Bey is the best voice there has ever been
“my girl started singin when she was 4, she was 9 when Vision of Love came out, so get yo fackts straight booboo” yea my ass came out singing when i was born too boo. lol and trust you to believe everyone word Beyonce’s dad says. I mean Beyonce says. Oop @ you for stanning for the devil sis. Maybe she aint the Devil but she’s working for him. I’d rather support talent than a packaged singer/”songwriter”/”mother”
Beyfan had better not be Blue Ivy cause it is, the devil’s spawn is inside this site.
-_-
They’re both talented…
LOFL THAT LAMB IS A ALLUMINATI MUTHA FUCKA, SHIT NIGGA YOU REAL STUPID THEN HAHAHAHA!!! AT least my bitch is human and running the industry while your flop is gasping for air
Beyoncé fans are the most annoying individuals on earth.
i love Beyonce but to get that 16 Grammys? Maybe 4 deserved Grammys and Bday but not 16 lol hell she deserves like 4 or something. But this isn’t a Beyonce post, Beyfan needs to wait till she robs someone’s song or baby before posting her Beyonce stanning comments
BYE!
“gasping for air” omg arent those Obsessed lyrics. Gosh Beyfan you must be either really obsessed w Mariah or a lamb
have fun here!
Please Beyfan…what happen to “Run the World” big ass flop…even after all the promotion she put into it. Didn’t “Irreplacable” save her B’day album,because “Ring the Alarm peaked and flop right after debuting, and Get Me Bodied was a flop!? LOL..Bey has had her share of misses darling.
The Queen Bey has NEVER had a flop album, the queen of cows Mariah, has had more than 4
first of all Mariah carey’s 3rd album Music Box ALONE has sold more then beyonce’s whole solo CAREER ..SO SHUT THE FUCK UP !!! ALL OF YOU KISS ASS BEYONCE FANS…Your not making any sense..Mariahs song vision of love is the reason beyonce even wanted to become a singer 0_o GET YOUR FACTS TOGETHER !!! Beyonce is the greatest alive performer and Mariah is the best Vocalist alive..GET OVER IT !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Haha. So let me jump in cause this Beystan person is pretty ridiculous. I hope you know people can buy their Grammys. Obviously, that’s what she’s been doing the whole time. So how are the Grammys legitimate awards if Beyonce has more than Aretha Franklin, Michael Jackson, Whitney Houston, Patti LaBelle, Mariah Carey, etc.? The Grammys are based ONLY on COMMERCIAL success, not CRITICAL success. #FAIL No.1
They are the actual musicians. Every singer doesn’t need to dance. Whitney and Mariah don’t dance and honestly, they both have said themselves they can’t. Mariah & Whitney got signed because they could SING. They captured their audiences because they could SING. #FAIL
@Beyfan I love how you say Mariah’s had 4 flopped albums. The MOST MISCONCIEVED ALBUM that people say flopped would be Glitter. I find it funny because Glitter went PLATINUM with sales of over 3 million. Pathetic. #FAIL AGAIN. Bahaha.
LOFL I see like ma Queen I’m pissin bitches off wit ma greatness. Yall just mad cause Im tellin aint nothin but the truth, so shut up bitches. 1st off at this fucked up pissed off nigga, MA girl is the queen of vocals and dancing and performing, nobody could or has done it better, and YES MA’AM she is better than Aretha (who also cant dance) Whitney (who couldnt dance) Patti who cant do nothin but yell, and this moo cow who cant even sang no mo, and every other bitch and nigga in the industry, Bey shits on them all and got the grammy’s to prove it, you sound so stupid motha fucka, how you gon buy some grammy’s? If thats true why didnt that stupid drunk ho you stan for buy some and get her motha fuckin life? And Nora, bitch bye, dont even preetend that Glitter aint a epic fail, it is and always has been it’s a joke, her label paid her to leave, if it did so good they woulda paid her to stay, retard, god you stupid ooh I cant even believe how dumb you have to be, I bet you put yo dog in the microwave didnt you, ya dumbass bastad, fuck you. And you know I’m right, my bitch dont have flop nowhere, while you bitch is covered with it now bow and keep it movin you fuckin stupid ho
SUCK BEY’S DICK BITCHES
The climax of We Belong Together is obviously lipped. Hero was live, except for “THE WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY and then a hero COOOMES along”. She planned on lipping the climax of CTTA but the playback never started, you can tell by the way she was doing the hand motions but there was no singing so he just did that last little bit live. But atleast it was live! I think that was all te lipping she did though! So proud of the Queen, she sounded AMAZING!
The real Queen dont have to lip sync, she sangs live everytime like you suppoosed to
@Beyfan I love how you say she’s the Queen of Vocals when she has NO MAJOR CHART success. Mariah has 18 No. 1 singles, the most WEEKS at No. 1 (79). Mariah’s 1st debut album sold 15 MILLION, Mariah’s 4th album is the BEST SELLING CHRISTMAS ALBUM with 15 million. By the time Mariah released her 3rd album, it already went DIAMOND! Beyonce isn’t even on Diamond status. You’re so pathetic. Haha. Well look at Aretha and Patti. They’re all LEGENDS. They’ve all sold waaay more than Beyonce. Haha. Regardless of it they danced or not, they still have sold more than Beyonce. And once AGAIN, The Grammys PROVE NOTHING! Mariah doesn’t need Grammys to validate her talent. Glitter is NOT an epic fail. Haha. THE MOVIE WAS. There’s a difference. Glitter, ONCE AGAIN, sold 3 MILLION! It went PLATINUM! Ha. Stupid dumb ass hoe. Haha. And you still can’t prove that Mariah’s flopped OTHER than Glitter, which she didn’t flop at. You just got schooled. Sit your ass down.
Beyfan is an idiot. Terrible grammar. Ignorant. Mariah >>>>>>>>>> that is all……….
@thestupidman is a pressed lil biatch cause I hoe”d his pussy asshole, yo bitch a flop, my queen is NOT, Mariah is so weak
Beyonce is a certified flop, only 25 mill ww lol. PATHETIC U & HER !!!!!!!!!!!
I KNEW @Thestupidman would be back, and lion on Bey, shithead, come back when the queen gets bought out of her contract, meaning she flopped so hard they fired her, I mean what kinda has been losser piece of shit can jus up and allow that to happen to them? Oh right YO MOOCOW HAHAHAHA, HER NEW ALBUM GON FLOP DONT NOBODY LIKE HER, she gave Justin Bieber who girls love a flop single, nobody checkin fo her, if ma bitch did a song with JB it’d take over radio and the world and have yall pressed and pissed, MA BITCH RUNS THE WORLD!!!!
Suck ma booty pussey bitch
Stop being so pathetic, all of you. I’m pretty sure your mommas taught you “if you don’t have anything nice to say, just say nothing.” So if you can’t appreciate either Mariah or Beyoncé, that’s fine, but don’t bother the rest of us with it. Grow the fuck up.
@Beyfan I LOVE how you didn’t have anything to say about my message. Why is that? Haha. I remember cause you got schooled. Let me school you again. First off, Mariah was dealing with TREMENDOUS amounts of physical stress. Try putting out an album every year in one decade. You obviously don’t think there’d be a breaking point? And 2, Virgin Records was half of the problem also. They didn’t know how to manage big artists like Mariah. Mariah had just came off of Sony being their TOP SELLING ARTIST WITH RECORDS OF OVER 150 MILLION RECORDS WORLDWIDE & 15 #1 SINGLES. Yeah. That’s what I thought. I find it funny how you claim Mariah’s new album is going to flop since its by far the MOST HIGHLY ANTICIPATED album of the year. #FAIL
Justin’s cover of MARIAH’s HIT ALL I WANT FOR CHRISTMAS IS YOU (sold 2 million+, re-ENTERS the charts EVERY SINGLE YEAR since 1994…how many years is that? Let me count. 17 YEARS!) was in the Top 20 thank you very much. #FAIL
Beyonce doesn’t run the world honey. Last I checked, Mariah does. You don’t hear people covering Beyonce songs on AI, The Voice, X-Factor, etc. They don’t. Know why? They aren’t INSPIRED by her. They’re inspired by MARIAH. Even Beyonce was haha. She said Mariah’s voice is a gift from God. Remember that interview? I sure do. Class dismissed.
This is so ratchet..I bet Beyfan ain’t even legal -_-
The fact that y’all are going back and forth between Beyonce and Mariah clearly shows y’all need more to talk about and we need them both back on deck STAT!..and LeToya too =+)
Mariah or (Beyonce for that matter) doesn’t need a bunch of trophies to prove her (their) remarkable success, it speaks for itself..Haters are gonna hate, while y’all is runnin’ your mouths, they runnin’ to the bank..cashin’ a grand diva check. These are two very rich bitches! LMCO!!!!
Your girl “Run’s The World”??? But her last album bombed and so did all of her singles. Her music is as tired as your dried uo conversations. F*ck up ! Also, that was Mariah’s song that she featured Justin on. The song was number on on the holiday charts, so know what you’re talking about, or keep it zipped. Also, Beyonce said Mariah’s “Vision Of Love” was one of the main reasons she wanted to song. Lol keep failing, cuz thats what u do best retard…
YOU BITCHES IS SOOOO PRESSED I FEEL SO SORRY FO YOU LAMBS, CAUSE ITS TIME FOR THE PERSON TO SLAWTER YOU BITCHES. Too the retareded ass bitch who wanna keep lyin n shit and act like Mooriah is the only cow to release a album every single year, bitch do yo fuckin history, Aretha, and Diana released albums every year for almost 20 years and you didnt hear about them goin batshit, yo tired ass 1 trick bitch is just a weak ho who is a hit and miss and in the last 10 years, majority of her bullshit ass whack music is a fuckin miss, so have severall fuckin seats tired ho. And you KNOW you lyin too you dumbass, they was singin Beyonce on all them shows, you retard plus they use her songs and image and name in more movies than yo queen of cows too. So eat that and shove yo face in my booty hole yo stupid ass fuckwad GET ON MA LEVEL AND BOW TO THE REAL QUEEN, LOFL Yea her shitty christmas album failed to do jack shit on any normal chart, cause her songs on it SUCKED. I feel sorry for you and her, you really think people who aint stupid ass lambs be interested in her dont you? Welcome to the real Worlld Bitch ass ho
Bitch stay pressed, Run The world is better and more popular than any song Mooriah has done in years and you know it too, you know you sing it bitch stop lyin. And nobody gives no flyin fucks about some fuckin holday charts, aint nobody checkin fo that shit. Geez you lambs be stupid as hell, but I cant expect yall to think like humans just lambs. Which is STUPID. Fuckwad, go eat a bag of baby dicks before I have to school you too.
HA! I WIN
So if it’s a CHRISTMAS album, why the fuck would it be on ANY OTHER CHART?! Yeah. Example of your idiotic ways. How is Mariah hit or miss? Dude, every single one of her albums has gone PLATINUM, except for one, but it went GOLD. So how does being in a movie define how well you can sing? Oh, let me tell you: IT DOESN’T. Yes, Beyonce is a good actress. Good for her. That doesn’t define her as an artist. It sure as hell doesn’t define Mariah as an actress also. Cause last I checked, every single album Mariah released in the 90s went PLATINUM! Oh! That’s what I thought. Shut yo ass up. I love how you say it failed to do anything. Mariah’s Christmas album back in 1994 is the BEST SELLING CHRISTMAS ALBUM OF ALL TIME with 15 MILLION RECORDS SOLD WORLDWIDE. Tell me again? What album are YOU talking about? Hahahahaha. How is Run the World more popular than any other Mariah song? More people know about Mariah’s TOP 20 HIT Obsessed and quote it waaaaay more than some Run the World shit. Come on now. Let’s be real. Who goes around saying, “Who run the world?” No trick. Obviously, the 15 MILLION people around the world care about the Holiday Charts since they bought, ONCE AGAIN, the BEST SELLING CHRISTMAS ALBUM of ALL TIME by Mariah Carey. Haha. You didn’t school ANYBODY. You just made yourself look more like an idiot. Go back to school and learn how to SPELL honey and form CORRECT, GRAMMATICAL sentences. Ha! “I WIN, YOU LOSE!”
I hate it how everybody here’s like “Omg she got her voice back”, you are no LAMB for sure. And now looking forward for her album because of this. That’s just low. Call yourself a Lamb? If you were, you would of knew all these years that she been having her voice. She has nodules, and if her doctor approves her singing then she will, if not, deal with it.