Mariah is a big star? hell not anymore Trent, She can be on the Xfactor because what is she doing right about now. It’s a Beyoncé, Rihanna, Lady Gaga, Katy Perry, Kesha, Bruno Mars, etc… world now. Mariah needs to eat humble pie and accept that shes nobody’s threat now.

And we agree again! To me though, Kelly Rowland on another reality series would be redundant. She needs to go home and reflect on what should be her next move.

Also, Mariah is too big a star to be a judge for this show. To me it would cheapen her brand. XFactor also hasn’t proven to be a the major hit Fox thought it would be.

Good-bye girl, you won’t be missed. i agree, Mariah is a huge star and way to big to be a judge on a talent show.

@ Hugo ….I don’t understand how you can diss one of the greatest singers of all time. Mariah Carey will never be a nobody. Her last album made platnium status! And the one before that! That was straight nonsense. She can still compete with all the artists you mentioned. And sing circles around each one without breaking a sweet! Now I believe Nicole is also a wonderful Singer. Killer love was an awesome album. She just needs better promotion and better videos!

LOL its funny how people are dissing her music career. She has one. Though its nit as successful as Beyonce nor Adele’s. She is an amazing Singer and the entertainment industry recognizes that. I’ve seen her perform with some of the greats. She is highly demanded. And if one performance don’t tell you why…this link will http://www.youtube.com/watch?nomobile=1&v=tE6SRBnDHx8

I vote for Kelly Rowland to take this spot, She needs U.S relevance she keeps running away for several months. and Maybe Nick Cannon can come from Americas got talent to this show. And MC as a judge that would be intimidating because you will feel like your performance and vocals will always be compared her vocal ability. Real talk, Kelly is too big for this show as well, she is scared to take a chance and take risk as a solo Artist she keeps playing it safe. She only took risk and went hard in DC. Having individual success scares alot of people and it scares her. She didn’t know what to do after that BET performance. So this show sort of puts her in a given spot light and guaranties at least one national televised performance.

…as if you’re Carey’s spokesperson, Trent.

Yup Mariah is simply to huge a star for this show. An appearance or judge/mentorship here and there is cool though.